SPY

S&P 500 benchmark

etf all instruments
+0.0
net board stance what this means
766.95
-0.4% · close 2026-09-08
-1% / +4% / +20%
1m / 3m / 12m
93%
of 52w range · -1.4% off high
11/26
hit rate as primary · α -15

Where we stand — 0 live ideas

No active idea holds this ticker. Anything below is history.

Where the winds are blowing

NET BOARD STANCE, LAST 60 EPISODES — rising = the besties are building this position, falling = abandoning it. Replayed from score_events; an idea counts from birth until its window closes.
PRICE VS SPY OVER THE SAME WINDOW, % — did the talk lead the tape or follow it?

Who's pushing which way

each voice's net push ON THIS TICKER — their most recent stance per idea × the idea's direction × strength, so supporting a bearish idea pushes down. Not conviction (that lives on the idea); this is direction of travel per person. what w= means

Jason
Jason w=1.27 macro
20 ideas (0 live) · last heard E237
+15
pushes up
PH
Philippe Laffont guest ×0.5
3 ideas (0 live) · last heard E227
+6
pushes up
Gavin Baker
Gavin Baker w=1.50 politics-market guest ×1.0
2 ideas (0 live) · last heard E238
+4
pushes up
MA
Mark Cuban guest ×0.5
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E198
+3
pushes up
KE
Keith Rabois guest ×1.0
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E207
+3
pushes up
Chamath
Chamath w=1.06 macro
33 ideas (0 live) · last heard E252
+2
pushes up
BI
Bill Gurley w=1.11 equities guest ×1.0
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E81
+2
pushes up
DO
Donald Trump guest ×0.5
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E184
+2
pushes up
AN
Andrew Schulz guest ×0.5
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E219
+2
pushes up
AA
Aaron Levie guest ×1.0
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E226
+2
pushes up
TU
Tucker Carlson guest ×0.5
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E231
+2
pushes up
PH
Phil Deutch guest ×0.5
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E238
+2
pushes up
BI
Bill Hagerty guest ×0.5
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E236
+1
pushes up
RY
Ryan Petersen guest ×1.0
2 ideas (0 live) · last heard E226
+0
neutral
JO
Joe Lonsdale w=1.00 politics-market guest ×1.0
2 ideas (0 live) · last heard E218
+0
neutral
Brad Gerstner
Brad Gerstner w=1.00 macro guest ×1.0
8 ideas (0 live) · last heard E250
-1
pushes down
RE
Reid Hoffman guest ×0.5
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E194
-2
pushes down
AN
Andrew Ross Sorkin guest ×0.5
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E225
-2
pushes down
EL
Elon Musk guest ×1.0
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E109
-3
pushes down
TH
Thomas Laffont w=1.00 equities guest ×1.0
1 idea (0 live) · last heard E232
-3
pushes down
Sacks
Sacks w=1.12 macro
29 ideas (0 live) · last heard E237
-4
pushes down
CY
Cyan Banister guest ×1.0
2 ideas (0 live) · last heard E220
-4
pushes down
BE
Ben Shapiro w=0.50 politics-market guest ×1.0
4 ideas (0 live) · last heard E238
-4
pushes down
EZ
Ezra Klein guest ×0.5
2 ideas (0 live) · last heard E223
-4
pushes down
LA
Larry Summers guest ×0.5
2 ideas (0 live) · last heard E223
-6
pushes down
Friedberg
Friedberg w=0.93 macro
24 ideas (0 live) · last heard E238
-14
pushes down

Track record on SPY

As a PRIMARY play the besties are 11 hit / 3 partial / 12 miss over 26 closed windows — credit 0.48, average α -14.8. Adjacent plays are listed but never scored.

ideacallplayverdictRαclosed
🌍 Soft-landing rally underprices the lag risk ▼ SHORT primary MISS -28.8% -57.5 2024-08-18
🌍 Supply-chain crunch tips the US into 1970s-style stagflation next year ▼ SHORT primary HIT +18.8% +37.6 2022-10-16
🏛️ Biden's 39.6% capital gains hike does not become law ▲ LONG primary PARTIAL +3.6% +0.0 2022-04-23
🏛️ Regulators backstop all uninsured deposits within days ▲ LONG primary PARTIAL +6.7% +0.0 2023-04-11
🌍 Markets are bottoming now - the Fed breaks something and the Fed put returns ▲ LONG primary HIT +18.4% +0.0 2023-10-01
🌍 Rapid reopening: weeks, not months ▲ LONG primary HIT +29.6% +0.0 2020-06-19
🌍 Everything is at all-time highs and the insiders are selling - de-risk ▼ SHORT primary HIT +13.4% +26.9 2022-11-13
🌍 Risk-off window: November to February ▼ SHORT primary MISS -3.2% -6.5 2026-02-07
🏛️ Trump's tariff threats are negotiating leverage and get settled down ▲ LONG adjacent PARTIAL +11.7% -1.1 2026-02-15
🌍 Tariff receipts plus cut savings re-rate the US and pull in global capital ▲ LONG primary HIT +14.8% +0.0 2025-12-13
📈 Hidden hedge-fund leverage forces another wave of equity selling ▼ SHORT primary MISS -12.6% -25.1 2024-11-09
📈 The equity beta trade is done — software back at fair value, alpha only from selection ▼ SHORT adjacent MISS -20.9% -42.2 2024-08-11
🌍 US population stall - births plus immigration collapse throttles the economy ▼ SHORT adjacent HIT +12.7% +20.7 2023-04-01
📈 Wall Street earnings estimates are wrong - the E resets, not just the multiple ▼ SHORT primary MISS -24.3% -48.7 2023-12-24
🏛️ A Democrat trifecta prices in the unrealized-gains wealth tax ▼ SHORT adjacent MISS -1.5% -11.2 2025-04-26
🌍 Rate hikes bite with a lag - back in recession next year ▼ SHORT primary MISS -5.6% -11.2 2023-08-13
🏛️ Ukraine endgame is an organized negotiated detente, not a Ukrainian win ▲ LONG primary HIT +12.9% +0.0 2023-06-24
🏦 Inflation hasn't peaked and the terminal rate is above what's priced ▼ SHORT adjacent PARTIAL +9.7% -11.1 2023-07-14
📈 Tech drawdown is in the eighth inning - the bottom is close ▲ LONG adjacent MISS -19.4% -10.9 2023-01-22
🌍 The 50bp kickoff cut means the Fed sees real pressure - earnings and asset values contract ▼ SHORT primary MISS -18.2% -36.4 2025-09-20
🏛️ Debt-ceiling standoff resolves — they raise it and keep spending ▲ LONG primary HIT +23.7% +0.0 2024-01-20
🌍 Dem sweep of Georgia runoffs cracks the market 30-40% ▼ SHORT primary MISS -17.0% -34.0 2021-05-11
🏛️ Ukraine ceasefire is weeks away — markets rally on the deal ▲ LONG primary MISS -17.3% +0.0 2022-06-19
🌍 Risk-off overhang lifts - equities and high-beta growth rally ▲ LONG primary HIT +33.1% +0.0 2024-11-03
📈 AI adoption disperses the S&P — short the index, own the category killers ▼ SHORT adjacent MISS -19.1% -44.9 2026-06-21
📈 Recession and an equity rally at the same time, because the Fed cuts ▲ LONG primary HIT +21.0% +0.0 2025-08-09
🏛️ Split government ends the spending orgy and blocks the interventionist response ▲ LONG adjacent MISS -3.0% -19.1 2023-11-05
🌍 US assets reprice with an emerging-market risk premium ▼ SHORT adjacent MISS -3.4% -32.1 2026-04-11
📈 Shrinking global equity float lifts prices regardless of fundamentals ▲ LONG primary PARTIAL +5.8% +0.0 2025-04-12
🏛️ Socialism goes national in the US and ratchets taxes and spending higher ▼ SHORT primary MISS -22.9% -45.9 2026-08-09
🌍 A second-term tariff-plus-tax-cut policy mix stokes stagflation ▼ SHORT primary MISS -10.3% -20.7 2025-06-20
🌍 COVID crash goes deeper — no V-shaped recovery ▼ SHORT primary MISS -65.5% -131.0 2021-03-19
🌍 Fed at zero for half a decade — get paid to be long equities ▲ LONG primary HIT +34.1% +0.0 2021-09-09
🏛️ Ukraine risk is already ring-fenced - even a nuclear incident barely moves markets ▲ LONG primary HIT +18.4% +0.0 2023-10-01
🌍 Payroll revisions expose an economy materially weaker than the headline data ▼ SHORT primary MISS -16.2% -32.5 2025-08-23

The tape — what was actually said

every capture on any idea holding SPY, newest first · quotes verbatim, timestamps deep-link into the episode

Chamath Chamath support ×2 ▼ on 🌍 Risk-off window: November to February E252 · 2025-11-22 ▶ 23:35
My gosh, this short Bitcoin thing has been a bonanza... Is it below 90? It is, right? It's like 87?... Watch out below.
Brad Gerstner Brad Gerstner support ×2 ▼ on 🌍 Risk-off window: November to February E250 · 2025-11-07 ▶ 39:46
Early in the year... Altimeter was positioned small... By May... we went to kind of extra large positioning and we've been there most of the year. And so now we're back to kind of medium, medium small positioning in the market... There's a pause as we head in over the course of the next couple months.
Chamath Chamath support ×2 ▼ on 🌍 Risk-off window: November to February E250 · 2025-11-07 ▶ 6:37
To be clear, we are very much getting into a phase of risk-off... We will be back firmly in risk-on mode in February, is my suspicion... Bitcoin is about to break through 100,000 to the downside, which I think is a psychological barrier that probably has another 5% or 10% more to run.
PH Phil Deutch oppose ×2 ▼ on 🏛️ Socialism goes national in the US and ratchets taxes and spending higher E238 · 2025-08-09 ▶ 54:57
I don't see that, but if you want to see that, you can, but it will swing back. This country is incredibly resilient, and I have complete faith in that resilience.
Gavin Baker Gavin Baker oppose ×2 ▼ on 🏛️ Socialism goes national in the US and ratchets taxes and spending higher E238 · 2025-08-09 ▶ 1:02:05
So they won't work. And I think that'll be a quick, that'll be like a quick end to socialism.
BE Ben Shapiro support ×2 ▼ on 🏛️ Socialism goes national in the US and ratchets taxes and spending higher E238 · 2025-08-09 ▶ 1:03:06
If things take a downturn, then the backlash is going to be a lot stronger than anything that any of us can say about the failures of Zoran Mamdani, because what it's going to be is, look, the rich got richer and we got poorer, and it's going to be a redox of 2007, 2008, but with a much, even further to the left than Obama ever was, and that I'm deeply afraid of.
Friedberg Friedberg support ×3 ▼ on 🏛️ Socialism goes national in the US and ratchets taxes and spending higher E238 · 2025-08-09 ▶ 53:24
My prediction will ring fruer than any of us hope. Socialism will sweep over this nation, I fear. And I think it's a cancer.
BE Ben Shapiro support ×2 ▲ on 🏛️ Trump's tariff threats are negotiating leverage and get settled down E238 · 2025-08-09 ▶ 31:06
Otherwise, China is able to sort of climb out the window, which is, I think, what they've done on everything from Nvidia chips to TikTok to their actual tariff rate, which I believe is now lower than the tariff rate we have against Canada.
Gavin Baker Gavin Baker support ×2 ▲ on 🏛️ Trump's tariff threats are negotiating leverage and get settled down E238 · 2025-08-09 ▶ 1:22:35
I would just say he showed his hand in April. He looked into the abyss and if it is clearly not working, he showed that he will change it.
Jason Jason support ×2 ▲ on 🏛️ Trump's tariff threats are negotiating leverage and get settled down E237 · 2025-08-01 ▶ 1:10:13
the shock and bore playbook is basically, Trump says something completely outrageous, shocking, everybody goes crazy, the media loses their mind, business leaders lose their mind. ... Trump comes in, sees all the stuff, and then he starts making these micro tweaks. So it's on the finish line, it's in the red zone, five-yard line, Trump comes in, and then he sticks it to them again with three or four extra asks, and then they wrap it up, and that this is becoming really effective.
Sacks Sacks support ×1 ▲ on 🏛️ Trump's tariff threats are negotiating leverage and get settled down E237 · 2025-08-01 ▶ 1:15:20
we said at the time that all of that was happening and Larry Summers was on the pod preaching doom, is that all of that was an opening bid. It was all the start to a negotiation. And we had to see where it ended up and that the administration still had to stick the landing. But I got to say based on EU, Japan and South Korea, this is looking really good right now.
Sacks Sacks support ×1 ▲ on 🌍 Tariff receipts plus cut savings re-rate the US and pull in global capital E237 · 2025-08-01 ▶ 1:07:02
It's about $2 trillion. It's effectively $2 trillion of stimulus into the US, but without money printing.
Sacks Sacks oppose ×1 ▼ on 🌍 Payroll revisions expose an economy materially weaker than the headline data E237 · 2025-08-01 ▶ 1:06:40
obviously the 3% number is way ahead of expectations. It's a fantastic number. It just feels like everything is humming on all cylinders here.
BI Bill Hagerty support ×1 ▲ on 🏛️ Trump's tariff threats are negotiating leverage and get settled down E236 · 2025-07-19 ▶ 1:10:40
Jameson is back now as the US Trade Representative and I'm very optimistic that we're going to see more trade flourish. President Trump knows how to do this. I've been with him in the trade negotiations. He knows exactly how to navigate this.
Jason Jason oppose ×1 ▼ on 🌍 Payroll revisions expose an economy materially weaker than the headline data E236 · 2025-07-19 ▶ 8:16
There's a lot of spending in there, as we've talked about here, putting that aside, it feels like the economy is in really great shape.
Gavin Baker Gavin Baker support ×1 ▲ on 🏛️ Trump's tariff threats are negotiating leverage and get settled down E236 · 2025-07-19 ▶ 3:06
I would say for everyone but China. You know, it is, and you know, we're, we've clearly reached some sort of deal with China, you know, rare earths for H20s and MI308Xs.
Jason Jason support ×2 ▲ on 🏛️ Trump's tariff threats are negotiating leverage and get settled down E236 · 2025-07-19 ▶ 2:44
And ultimately, don't we look at the tariff situation and say, despite the shock and awe of the opening salvo, it's quite a boring position now. It just seems to be reciprocity and reasonable reciprocity at that.
Chamath Chamath support ×3 ▲ on 🌍 Tariff receipts plus cut savings re-rate the US and pull in global capital E234 · 2025-07-04 ▶ 48:45
And so as long as that's the case, I think you're going to continue to have a bid for equities. If all of a sudden the MAG 7 decided to delist and not be American companies, and all of a sudden showed up in the CAC 50 in France, yeah, we'd be in big trouble. But I don't think that's going to happen. And so as long as there's American ingenuity and American supremacy, again, which goes back to the other thing, which is we can't kill these golden geese, nor should we kill the emerging and growing golden goose, which is AI. And as long as those things are the same, there will be a constant bid for American assets.
Friedberg Friedberg support ×2 ▼ on 🌍 US assets reprice with an emerging-market risk premium E234 · 2025-07-04 ▶ 52:05
In the last 10 years, US treasuries held by foreign holders has declined from 34%. This is a good thing, not a bad thing. I mean, it's good in one context. But my point is people, foreign countries and foreign businesses and foreign investors aren't holding US treasuries as much as they used to.
Chamath Chamath oppose ×3 ▼ on 🌍 US assets reprice with an emerging-market risk premium E234 · 2025-07-04 ▶ 46:08
So, I don't know, I think that it's part of the fact that until we run surpluses and or completely eliminate the debt, there will always be a reason to be somewhat short the dollar. But the reality is that a lot of people still want to own these assets more than what they want to own any other asset. And those assets are dollar denominated. And so as long as that continues to hold in the push and pull, it will be a slow bleed, but it's probably manageable.
Jason Jason support ×2 ▲ on 🏛️ Trump's tariff threats are negotiating leverage and get settled down E233 · 2025-06-28 ▶ 1:26:23
He starts with a bang and then he falls back to a reasonable position that the markets can digest. So you just have to take a 90 day view of everything he's doing and then you'll be fine.
Sacks Sacks support ×1 ▲ on 🏛️ Trump's tariff threats are negotiating leverage and get settled down E233 · 2025-06-28 ▶ 1:25:06
any time that the media tries to sow doom or spread panic about the Trump administration's policies, that's a good time to buy.
Chamath Chamath support ×3 ▲ on 🌍 Tariff receipts plus cut savings re-rate the US and pull in global capital E233 · 2025-06-28 ▶ 1:21:36
I think that if Powell starts an aggressive cutting program, either because he has to, or because he's trying to keep his job, I mean, man, you could see the S&P at 7,000.
Friedberg Friedberg oppose ×2 ▲ on 🌍 Tariff receipts plus cut savings re-rate the US and pull in global capital E233 · 2025-06-28 ▶ 1:19:51
So one argument here might be that we're actually not necessarily seeing an improvement in the fundamental business environment. We're not seeing record revenue across the board.
Friedberg Friedberg support ×3 ▼ on 📈 AI adoption disperses the S&P — short the index, own the category killers E232 · 2025-06-21 ▶ 1:19:41
I think it's the first time you could probably argue that you could go short the S&P and pick a couple of winners. ... I do think that this is such a transformative moment that if you really have a sense for what's possible, you could start to see category killers emerge out of the S&P, and it's an opportunity to short the S&P and pick a couple of winners.