+32.7
net board stance
what this means
53.33
-3.0% · close 2026-09-08
-10% / +29% / -21%
1m / 3m / 12m
-56%
vs SPY since 2025-05-17
40%
of 52w range · -29.2% off high
1/2
hit rate as primary · α +14
Where we stand — 1 live idea
| idea | call | play | conviction | contributes | flag | eval in |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 📈 Web2 buyouts: the flaccid-asset M&A wave | ▲ LONG | primary | 32.7 | +32.7 | — | 130d |
Where the winds are blowing
NET BOARD STANCE, LAST 60 EPISODES —
rising = the besties are building this position, falling = abandoning it. Replayed from
score_events; an idea counts from birth until its window closes.
PRICE VS SPY OVER THE SAME WINDOW, % — did the
talk lead the tape or follow it?
Who's pushing which way
each voice's net push ON THIS TICKER — their most recent stance per idea × the idea's direction × strength, so supporting a bearish idea pushes down. Not conviction (that lives on the idea); this is direction of travel per person. what w= means
What resolves next
kill dates for the live ideas holding this ticker — each one turns into a scored verdict on that date, whether we like it or not
Track record on PYPL
As a PRIMARY play the besties are 1 hit / 0 partial / 1 miss over 2 closed windows — credit 0.5, average α +14.0. Adjacent plays are listed but never scored.
| idea | call | play | verdict | R | α | closed |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 🏛️ Financial deplatforming becomes the next big political fight | ▼ SHORT | primary | HIT | +65.9% | +71.1 | 2022-08-06 |
| 📈 Payment processors are middlemen with no pricing power | ▼ SHORT | primary | MISS | -14.4% | -43.1 | 2024-08-18 |
| 📈 Fintech feature consolidation: licensed platforms become consumer-finance superpowers | ▲ LONG | adjacent | MISS | -71.3% | -157.1 | 2026-08-06 |
The tape — what was actually said
every capture on any idea holding PYPL, newest first · quotes verbatim, timestamps deep-link into the episode
I will make a prediction. I think that eBay and PayPal are probably the beginning of a wave of mega deals of flaccid digital businesses that can be revived with the blue chew of capital and the right operator... folks that are AI native are looking at first generation digital native businesses that have become mature and old and stale and aren't run by the founders anymore... there's a couple dozen of them.
this is probably not the final clearing price. I think the price is probably another 10 to 15 percent higher from here. And I will say that there's a certain individual that must look very closely at putting in a competitive bid. ... a shot across the bow for Visa and MasterCard. ... They have enough of these things to go end to end on their own rails.
The first takeaway for me was the value of Stripe's ecosystem is probably underappreciated. ... But in the report, they talk about all the additional products that they're able to build around core payments. And one of them is the billing product. It's half a billion dollars a year of ARR. That's just incredible. And I think if they figure out network effects inside of the Stripe ecosystem, that's interesting. So that's first, which is the hub and spoke of payments being at the center, but all of these other incremental services.
I have one company myself and I'm proud to say I've sold no shares of my Robinhood. I keep all my Robinhood shares. ... Their whole plan was always to provide the full suite of services.
your real margin, your real gross profit on that transaction is 25 basis points, 10%. So really, of your 25 million of revenue, you only have 2.5 million of true net revenue.
their margins and their LTV to CAC or their return on invested capital, it looks the same or in some cases worse than the traditional financial services businesses that they're meant to disrupt
And so since August, what you've seen are the large leading edge public fintech companies just get absolutely murdered
this could be the buying opportunity for a lot of these equities if you believe in them long-term. I saw Dan Loeb is placing a bunch of bets. He bought some Uber, he bought Nvidia.
The thing to remember about all these businesses, Stripe, Adyen, PayPal, is that they're middlemen businesses, which by definition means that they don't have pricing power... So your margins over time tend to be compressed and over time your share of profits tend to be compressed and you have to give up a lot... So the real takeaway is that this is a very tough, tough business that is a race to the bottom.
CL
Claire Cormier Thielke
support ×1
▲ on
📈 Fintech feature consolidation: licensed platforms become consumer-finance superpowers
E82 · 2022-05-24
▶ 0:28
China's e-commerce percentage is about 25% of their overall retail. Here it's about 14%. Again, y'all are smart. We can see where this is going. ... In China, about 85-ish percent of their transactions are mobile. Here, that's barely 30%. Where is that going? How does that work? Again, you can see what's happening.
we've seen sort of random decision making that seems arbitrary by a lot of these technology companies, and the payments companies. Friedberg was mentioning Visa and MasterCard earlier in the group chat.
And they're not just doing it on speech. They're also taking away your right to engage in payments, in transactions, to earn a living. And unless we stop this now, it'll keep going.
The idea that you can deep platform one or the other or fire them from their job or prevent them from having access to the money that they've earned or preventing other people from donating money, that's really, it's a really low bar. ... And I think when you normalize this kind of behavior, it's a very slippery slope.
wrote a piece for Barry Weiss' substack talking about how financial de-platforming would be the next wave of online censorship ... What I could not have predicted is that it would occur in our mild-mannered neighbor to the north and that the reprisals would be directed by the government itself, not just a consortium of private actors.
And you know, what was PayPal doing? I wrote a story for Barry Weiss, for her substack about how PayPal was taking the lead in financial deplatforming. They were working with the ADL and the SPLC to kick to identify groups to kick off their platform. So that's what management was spending their cycles on figuring out how not to grow, how to kick people off their platform and trying to figure out how to get more people on it. ... You can waste your management cycles on stuff like that. Now their stock is down 25%.
I wrote a piece called the No Buy List where I basically you had companies like PayPal and some of these other financial firms were starting to deny service to customers, to users based on their political affiliations. ... if this equity auditors tells you, well, look, I don't think it's equitable to allow these conservative groups to, you know, be a user of your product. Well, what's the company going to do? They're going to have to listen to that. ... And that is a plausible scenario, given that it's already occurred.
Right, but who are the big winners in this wave of consolidation going to be at the end of the day? It's going to be Square, it's going to be Stripe, it's going to be PayPal, it's going to be the big online companies, not the offline legacy banks.
I have a big thesis and a big belief that over the next decade, we're going to see those five categories start to merge and you're going to have three to five superpowers that are going to offer a consolidated stack of services.
And so if Square can basically continue to acquire or build adjacent features that consolidates the financial services stack for their consumers, the stock market will reward these guys. They'll be able to grow and buy things for free for the next five or 10 years. ... If you can see folks acquiring adjacent features, or if you can see folks taking expense lines and turning them into revenue lines, these are, in my opinion, sure bet companies that compound forever in the public markets.
If you try to deny Americans their right to access the new economy, we see no reason for your company to get any bigger. We're going to oppose every acquisition you ever do. ... I'm predicting right now that financial deplatforming is going to be the big hot potato, political hot potato over the next year. This is the next wave of censorship.